Beethoven to Perfection

In recent times, pianist Hans Richter-Haaser has established a name as ossibly the most distinguished Beethoven specialist since Schnabel. It was easy at his recital last night (Bulawayo City Hall) to see why.


His intellectual authority and architectural grasp were obvious at once in the two early works – the C minor Sonata, Op. 10, No. 1, and the Op. 34 Variations in F. The faultless poise of his readings did not preclude humour (as in the playful second subject in the Sonata’s first movement), violence (the dramatic coda of the finale), or gentleness (the final reprise of the variations’ theme), but these features were rightly held subservient to the relative formality of these early pieces.

In the later works he began to take risks. The hammered, obstinate octaves in the first movement of the F major Sonata, Op. 54, had the authentic, compulsive rudeness of Beethoven’s middle years, and Herr Richter-Haaser’s possessed but superbly calculated account of the companion “Waldstein” Sonata was an unalloyed triump – an astonishing performance.

Faster Speed

I thought, though, that the moto perpeuo finale of the F major Sonata, taken at a faster speed than in Herr Richter-Haaser’s own recording, ran slightly out of control in the final exciting moments. I also felt – despite the pianist’s enormous emotional commitment – that the momentum and integrity of the first movement of the C Minor Sonata, Op. 111 (Beethoven’s last), were lost in some over-observance of Beethoven’s tempo and expression markings, and in a certain loss of control at the climax. But he gave a tremendous account of the ineffable Arietta finale. His pianissimo playing was withdrawn and truly inning, the legato expressive yet appropriately lean, and the trills and figurations of the great quasi-cadenza luminous and fulfilled. It was a memorable account of awesomely great music.

2 Replies to “Beethoven to Perfection”

  1. I was pleased to find this resource.
    I have often remembered this Hans Richter-Haaser concert. For the occasion I travelled with my parents from Gwelo to Bulawayo on the chartered Guinea Fowl School bus. Now, thanks to this critique, I have been able to find the date of the concert, and an account of the pieces played that evening.
    My early interest in classical music has led me to pursue a career in music which I enjoy to this day.
    Thank you
    Moya Michalakis, née Brayshaw

  2. Great to hear from you, thank you Moya for commenting and giving us your personal account of this concert. I am so pleased Marshall’s critque helped you to recall details of the concert.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.